OK, let's get a backlog of screenshots out of the way.

 You have gotta love these reflections! Above, I had 3 reflections from Jay as well as a valid decoded signal!

 A lot of time we seem to be seeing these partial signals. Meteor scatter? Atmospherics?
Beats me.

Below may be the first trace that I have for Bill, VE3IQB. Looks good but no decode.

This was just after I swung the yagi to the midpoint between he and Jay, VE3SWS.

It is now 18 degrees off of both of them.

Jay is the first signal and I believe that is Bill about 50hz above on the next segment.